Frequently Asked Questions

Do you make any cupcakes that are gluten-free, dairy-free, or egg-free?

We make a line of cupcakes that are free of gluten, dairy, and eggs. These are made in the same kitchen as our other products, but at a dedicated time after a rigorous sanitation process and using a separate set of all ingredients.

Do your cupcake contain nuts?

We are not a dedicated nut free facility nor do we source exclusively from nut free manufacturers, however as of September 2021 we no longer use peanuts or tree nuts in our kitchen.

Do you do custom cupcakes?

We do custom cupcakes for any occasion. We have talented artists in store that can work with you to dream up the perfect design for your event. We ask for 7-10 days notice and the best way to order is to call us at 781-444-4995.

How do I place a large order

If you are looking to place a custom order for a large event or a selection of our cupcakes in quantities over 5 dozen, please email i[email protected], and we will work with you to get you exactly what you want.

What can I order online? 

You can order any amount of cupcakes for pick up or a minimum of 1 dozen for delivery online. You will be able to choose anything from our Everyday and current Seasonal menu. If you are looking to order anything other than what is offered daily, including special flavors, custom orders, or large orders over 10 dozen, please e-mail [email protected] and we will work with you to get you exactly what you want. You can also place orders over the phone anytime during our business hours by calling the store at 781-444-4995.

I am buying cupcakes for an event the following day... what should I do with them overnight? 

For maximum freshness we recommend freezing cupcakes until the night before you wish to serve them. Take them out of the freezer and allow them to come to room temperature- at least 4 hours is recommended.

Do my cupcakes need to be refrigerated?

Treat cupcakes do not need to be refrigerated, nor do we recommend it. Our cupcakes are best served at room temperature and will be fine left out for about 2 days. If you want to save leftover cupcakes, they also freeze well. When taking them out of the freezer, we recommend giving them at least 4 hours to come to room temperature before enjoying.

Do you sell mini cupcakes?

We sell minis as a sampler pack of a dozen. The sampler contains 1 each of our Everyday and Seasonal flavors.

How many cupcake flavors do you offer daily?

We offer at least 12 flavors in our case daily. We have 8 Everyday Flavors and 4 Seasonal flavors. We also have gluten-free flavors, our Treat Others Well cupcake of the month, and anything else that we want to surprise you with!

Can you bring the make-a-treat bar to my home, office, or event? 

We have two options for making cupcakes at your place instead of ours. We offer kits”that include 6 cupcakes, a tub of frosting, and 6 toppings of your choice. We also offer individual cupcake kits (1 cupcake, a portion of frosting, and three toppings). You can order as many kits as you need for your purposes.

Can I order Seasonal Menu items that are not currently offered?

Many of our seasonal cupcakes can be made out of season by special request. As with any custom order, we would ask for 7-10 days notice. Some flavors have a 6 minimum out of season, and some have a dozen minimum, depending on the complexity of the flavor. Just ask! We'll let you know if it is something we are able to offer.